Unfortunately, I can't comment about it because I haven't played the game yet (but I'll solve this situation very soon )... But for those who have already played: What would be your grade?
I'd rate it a 4.5/5 stars. It's honestly a really good game, the physics is one of the best I've seen in the genre. They have a track generator which functions really well, I've played a lot of the generated tracks and I've enjoyed most of them so far. The rallycross is really amazing too!
My grade would be basically the same as your and I think their track generator are really a good one (their feaures are just great ).
I haven't played the game yet, either but I do think that there is a lot more to be happy about the features than there is to cry about in Dirt 4.
This Dirt 4 game is great for the experienced, novice, car buff and adrenaline junkie as well- and the handling and traction in Dirt 4 is pretty nice also. Dirt 4 is good for anyone, no matter what ability you have !
I'm a really huge fan of DiRT Rally because of the realism of the game, and I'm just glad the devs brought some of that to DiRT 4 by adding the 'realistic' and 'gamer' options. So I would give it a 3.5/5 for that.